Stone House Coin Shop, Inc.

Great experience at the Stone House Coin Shop. The staff is professional & knowledgeable. They are honest, helpful & made the process of selling my dads collection easy. I highly recommend.

Excellent Fair Knowledgeable And will always work out a great deal! Look for gold jewelry coins and silver. Stop in ask for Lou. I had a terrific experience

Great experience today with entire staff. Brought my childhood coin collection in to sell since no other family member was interested in keeping. They took the time to go through each coin, proof set and currency in my collection. Not only did they offer a fair price, but also took the time to explain why. I highly recommend bringing not only your old coins, but also gold, silver and jewelry. They are honest and professional. A truly exceptional experience!

Best coin shop around!! The workers are honest and informative

Friendly, professional staff

Extremely knowledgeable, friendly and fair. Had a great experience and highly recommend.

5 star review

I’ve been in the process of going through saved family items recently - some of which I wasn’t sure if it had value. My jeweler in Morristown recommended Stone House, assuring me that they were both fair and honest. That they were! I’ve made 3 trips, and each time I’ve left delighted with the experience. They quickly and expertly evaluated what I brought to them…and patiently gave me an unexpected education on the assessment of the pieces I brought to the store. The business is not limited to coins, jewelry can also be assessed. No matter what the valuations are, these gentlemen make you feel glad you stopped by.

After having multiple disappointing experiences with similar businesses in my town, I came across Stone House. What a delight! In addition to the notable attention to detail and unbeatable quality service, as a repeat customer, what matters more than competitive pricing is the effort spent remembering each customer and learning that person’s story. Thank you for your honesty. Thank you for valuing your customers so much that you consistently strive to offer unbeatable pricing. Thank you for remembering me by name. I remember you with my continued loyal service. See you soon!

ABSOLUTELY AMAZING EXPERIENCE. I read the reviews and figured it had to be a good spot. Went in to buy some foreign coins and everyone was so nice and helpful. Was a super quick trip but they were more than happy to help me with all of my questions. If I could rate above 5 stars I truly would. If you want to know how to run a business, go here and learn from these people!

I am the founder of a non-profit dog rescue called Buddha Pooch Dog Rescue Project. I went in to get some guidance on on some silver coins I personally had in hopes to help fund a dog I pulled from the Newark shelter. Not only did my experience exceed my expectations, the shop donated $100 to my cause of saving local NJ dogs. To say the least, there were tears shed & I was able to help this dog in need. Working in rescue, you realize that there are a lot of cruel people in the world but Stone House Coin Shop exemplifies the best of humanity.

My father left us a silver bar and a number of silver and gold coins. I knew these would be worth something but I didn't realize they would be worth a five-figure amount. I had gone to another coin shop first for a quote, before going to Stone House. Stone House beat the offer from the other shop by about $2,000. I was really, really impressed with their honesty and great service. I'll definitely be back when I have more gold or silver items to sell. Easy 5 stars.